Micro-scale model comparison (benchmark) at the moderately complex forested site Ryningsnäs

Ivanell, Stefan; Arnqvist, Johan; Avila, Matias; Cavar, Dalibor; Chavez-Arroyo, Roberto Aurelio; Olivares-Espinosa, Hugo; Peralta, Carlos; Adib, Jamal; Witha, Björn

This article describes a study in which modellers were challenged to compute the wind field at a forested site with moderately complex topography. The task was to model the wind field in stationary conditions with neutral stratification by using the wind velocity measured at 100 m at a metmast as the only reference. Detailed maps of terrain elevation and forest densities were provided as the only inputs, derived from airborne laser scans (ALSs) with a resolution of 10 m inline-formula× 10 m covering an area of 50 km inline-formula× 50 km, that closely match the actual forest and elevation of the site. The participants were free to apply their best practices for the simulation to decide the size of the domain, the value of the geostrophic wind, and every other modelling parameter. The comparison of the results with the measurements is shown for the vertical profiles of wind speed, shear, wind direction, and turbulent kinetic energy. The ALS-based data resulted in reasonable agreement of the wind profile and turbulence magnitude. The best performance was found to be that of large-eddy simulations using a very large domain. For the Reynolds-averaged Navier–Stokes type of models, the constants in the turbulence closure were shown to have a great influence on the yielded turbulence level, but were of much less importance for the wind speed profile. Of the variety of closure constants used by the participating modellers, the closure constants from citxref_text.1#bib1.bibx45Sogachev and Panferov (#bib1.bibx452006) proved to agree best with the measurements. Particularly the use of inline-formulaCμ≈0.03 in the inline-formulakinline-formulaε model obtained better agreement with turbulence level measurements. All except two participating models used the full detailed ground and forest information to model the forest, which is considered significant progress compared to previous conventional approaches. Overall, the article gives an overview of how well different types of models are able to capture the flow physics at a moderately complex forested site.



Ivanell, Stefan / Arnqvist, Johan / Avila, Matias / et al: Micro-scale model comparison (benchmark) at the moderately complex forested site Ryningsnäs. 2018. Copernicus Publications.


12 Monate:

Grafik öffnen


Rechteinhaber: Stefan Ivanell et al.

Nutzung und Vervielfältigung: